Statutes that protect the rights of the owners of trade secrets protect against ‘misappropriation’ of confidential information, which requires a defendant to take or use the trade secret without permission. The inevitable disclosure doctrine can prevent an employee from working for another when the new job would inevitably require the…
The Business Divorce Law Report
Competition and the Value of a Business are Closely Tied
Enterprise goodwill is the expectation that a business has in the continued patronage by its customers, regardless of the individuals involved. Personal goodwill is the expectation of continued patronage because of an individual’s continued participation in the business. Personal goodwill is not an asset owned by a business, but it…
What Now? The Internal Affairs Doctrine Meets the Single Enterprise Doctrine
The ‘Internal Affairs Doctrine’ requires that a court apply the law from the state in which a business was organized to disputes among the shareolders or LLC members. The ‘Single Enterprise Theory’ permits a court to treat multiple entities with common ownership as though they were one. In disputes involving…
No Foul in Dissociated LLC Member’s Refusal to Cooperate in PPP Loan
A ‘passive’ member with no rights or responsibilities in the management of a limited liability company cannot be held liable for refusing to participate in a PPP loan application. Dissociated LLC members with no management rights can withhold their voluntary consent to proposed actions. The waiver of fiduciary duties in…
NJ Court Rejects Choice of Delaware Law Under RULLCA
The Internal Affairs doctrine requires a court to apply the law of the state where a business was formed, or organized, to disputes between the owners regardless of the circumstances. New Jersey courts have applied a more traditional analysis of conflict of laws issues and may refuse to apply the…
The Equitable Value of an Oppressed Minority Shareholder’s Interest
A New Jersey Court conducing the valuation of a business may use any technique or method generally acceptable in the financial community. The application of a minority discount is a question of law, but likely will be based on the factual determinations of the court about the culpability of the…
Absence of Competitive Advantage – The First Line of Defense to Trade Secret Lawsuits
The touchstone of a trade secret is that it provides the owner of the information with a competitive advantage in their market. Courts look at the cost of development, the difficulty in duplicating and measurable benefits to ascertain whether a bona fide trade secret exists. The first step in the…
Reasonable Expectations Define Oppression of Minority LLC Member
Limited Liability Company laws in New Jersey and many states provide a cause of action for the oppression of minority members of company against those in control of the business. Oppression of a minority LLC member is measured by the reasonable expectations of the minority member in those states that…
Minority Shareholder Oppression Under New Jersey Law
Minority shareholders of a closely held corporation may be subjected to oppressive conduct by the controlling majority that deprives them of the benefits of their investment. Oppressed minority shareholder actions vindicate the rights of the minority owner to participate in the management and share in the economic benefits of the…
Hostility Among Owners Blocks LLC Derivative Lawsuit
A plaintiff seeking to bring a derivative claim on behalf of a corporation, limited liability company or limited partnership must be “suitable” and represent the interests of the business. A member of a limited liability company may sue individually to recover or protect the member’s individual right. New Jersey law…